Search: in
Archi-writing
Archi-writing in Encyclopedia Encyclopedia
  Tutorials     Encyclopedia     Videos     Books     Software     DVDs  
       





Archi-writing

Archi-writing is a term used by French philosopher Jacques Derrida in his attempt to re-orient the relationship between speech and writing.

Derrida argued that as far back as Plato, speech had been always given priority over writing. In the West, phonetic writing was considered as a secondary imitation of speech, a poor copy of the immediate living act of speech. Derrida argued that in later centuries philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau and linguist Ferdinand de Saussure both gave writing a secondary or parasitic role. In Derrida's essay Plato's Pharmacy, he sought to question this prioritising by firstly complicating the two terms speech and writing.

According to Derrida, this complication is visible in the Greek word pharmakon, which meant both "cure" and "poison." Derrida noted that Plato argued that writing was "poisonous" to memory, since writing is a mere repetition, as compared to the living memory required for speech. Derrida points out however, that since both speech and writing rely upon repetition they cannot be completely distinguished.

In the neologism archi-writing, "archi-" meaning "origin, principle or telos," attempts to go beyond the simple division of writing/speech. Archi-writing refers to a kind of writing that precedes both speech and writing. Derrida argued that Archi-writing is, in a sense, language, in that it is already there before we use it, it already has a pregiven, yet malleable, structure/genesis, which is a semi-fixed set-up of different words and syntax. This fixedness is the writing to which Derrida refers, just such a 'writing' can even be seen in cultures that do not employ writing, it could be seen in notches on a rope or barrel, fixed customs, or placements around the living areas.

Philosopher John R. Searle[1] argued that most of Derrida's concepts were characterized by a "breathtaking implausibility," being based on an "eccentric reading of the history of Western philosophy" which overlooks or misstates many important details of philosophy and language; e.g., Derrida distorts Saussure's structural linguistics.

References

  1. Searle, John R. (1983) "The Word Turned Upside Down," The New York Review of Books, Volume 30, Number 16, October 27, 1983.






Source: Wikipedia | The above article is available under the GNU FDL. | Edit this article



Search for Archi-writing in Tutorials
Search for Archi-writing in Encyclopedia
Search for Archi-writing in Videos
Search for Archi-writing in Books
Search for Archi-writing in Software
Search for Archi-writing in DVDs
Search for Archi-writing in Store




Advertisement




Archi-writing in Encyclopedia
Archi-writing top Archi-writing

Home - Add TutorGig to Your Site - Disclaimer

©2011-2013 TutorGig.info All Rights Reserved. Privacy Statement